Sept. 25, 2025

What’s the Real Advantage of a Small Podcast Audience? | 020

What’s the Real Advantage of a Small Podcast Audience? | 020

Do you ever feel like your podcast is too small to matter? The reality is that smaller shows hold the biggest advantage: intimacy. We break down why fewer listeners mean more connection, faster trust, and stronger influence. Instead of chasing downloads, we shift the focus to impact.

You’ll hear simple strategies that turn a micro-audience into loyal fans and even paying clients: ask for feedback, mention listeners by name, create one-page resources that solve real problems, and host small live sessions that build community. This is your starter playbook for transforming a handful of listeners into a thriving, engaged audience.

Highlights:

  • Why small podcasts can outpace big shows in community building.
  • How to stop chasing downloads and measure success by impact.
  • The role of niche content in creating listener loyalty.
  • Simple engagement moves you can implement immediately.
  • How intimacy and connection convert listeners into clients.

Ready to Launch Your Own Podcast or Need to Realign your Current One. Take Action Now!

Download Your Free Copy of the Podcast Playbook: https://amplifyou.com/podcast-playbook-download/


Connect with Braden and AmplifYou:

Website: https://amplifyou.com

LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/bradenricketts

LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/amplifyoupodcasting

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/amplifyou.ca

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/AMPLIFYOU.ca

YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@amplifyoupodcastnetwork

Troy Lacher:

Hey, amplifiers, welcome back to the podcast

Troy Lacher:

playbook. I hope that you've all been enjoying our episodes on

Troy Lacher:

the best practices of podcasting, and they really do

Troy Lacher:

appreciate those of you that keep coming back week after week

Troy Lacher:

to learn more on how to amp up your podcasting journey. There

Troy Lacher:

may not be a lot of you, but it's with heartfelt appreciation

Troy Lacher:

that I see you keep coming back, which really brings me to my

Troy Lacher:

topic today. Whether you're just starting out your podcasting

Troy Lacher:

journey or you've been doing it for many years, we all start to

Troy Lacher:

look at the big shows, you know, the ones hitting the crazy

Troy Lacher:

download numbers, the Joe rogans, the Seth, godins and all

Troy Lacher:

those other giants that we look up to, they are the ones that

Troy Lacher:

are posting about milestones and getting press that we want, and

Troy Lacher:

suddenly we're wondering, is this enough? Are we doing

Troy Lacher:

enough? Is this worth it? But here's the truth, smaller

Troy Lacher:

doesn't mean weaker. If you've got a fewer than 1000 downloads

Troy Lacher:

per episode, you're not falling behind. You've actually got a

Troy Lacher:

huge advantage. So the reason you can't compare yourself to

Troy Lacher:

those giant shows is because they're not playing the same

Troy Lacher:

game as you. These guys are built on big budgets, big teams

Troy Lacher:

with big reach, and with that size comes distance. They can't

Troy Lacher:

talk to every listener, they can't answer every email. They

Troy Lacher:

can't make every episode feel personal, but you can. That's

Troy Lacher:

the beauty of being small. You're speaking directly to the

Troy Lacher:

people who care about what you're saying, and that's what

Troy Lacher:

makes your show powerful. Those big numbers, they don't always

Troy Lacher:

equal real success. Sure, we all want that number download to say

Troy Lacher:

that we're hitting reaching so many people, but does reaching

Troy Lacher:

so many people it really matter if they're not truly paying

Troy Lacher:

attention, if we're influencing the journeys of a few, then

Troy Lacher:

we're making the impact that is far more meaningful than chasing

Troy Lacher:

numbers, because those Few aren't just listeners. Those are

Troy Lacher:

the people whose lives, businesses or decisions are

Troy Lacher:

being shaped by what you share, and that kind of impact is

Troy Lacher:

lasting. A small audience gives you room to do things that big

Troy Lacher:

shows simply can't you can build real trust because people feel

Troy Lacher:

like you're talking straight to them. You can focus your content

Troy Lacher:

so solve specific problems instead of watering it down for

Troy Lacher:

a larger group, and you create real loyalty when listeners feel

Troy Lacher:

connected, not just entertained, of course, they want both, but

Troy Lacher:

connections more important. Think about it, even if a few

Troy Lacher:

100 people are consistently listening and applying what you

Troy Lacher:

share, that's huge. Those are the people who recommend you,

Troy Lacher:

who will become clients, who bring others along. That's the

Troy Lacher:

long term impact of this. And here's where it gets even more

Troy Lacher:

interesting, if your audience is small and specific, so you've

Troy Lacher:

got your niche, say, midlife entrepreneurs, first time real

Troy Lacher:

estate investors, or wellness coaches, you can really lean

Troy Lacher:

into that. They're not looking for the broad, generic advice.

Troy Lacher:

They want content that speaks directly to their challenges.

Troy Lacher:

That's where you can shine. By narrowing your focus, you're

Troy Lacher:

making your podcast feel like it was made just for them, and when

Troy Lacher:

people feel understood, they stick around. So how do we serve

Troy Lacher:

these micro audiences? Well? Well, first off, ask for

Troy Lacher:

feedback, use polls or emails and shape episodes around what

Troy Lacher:

they want. Second, acknowledge your listeners. Mention them by

Troy Lacher:

name. Thank them for the reviews. Highlight their wins

Troy Lacher:

that they've shared with you. Third, create small extras. A

Troy Lacher:

one page checklist tied to an episode can feel like a big

Troy Lacher:

value add. So if you're giving specific information, give them

Troy Lacher:

something downloadable, so that they don't need to come back in

Troy Lacher:

and, you know, re listen to the podcast over and over to catch

Troy Lacher:

everything you're saying. Give them a checklist. Build a

Troy Lacher:

community, even a small Facebook group or a circle space keeps

Troy Lacher:

that conversation going after the episode is over. Do live

Troy Lacher:

sessions, 10 people on a zoom call can create stronger bonds

Troy Lacher:

than 1000s of downloads ever could share the listener

Troy Lacher:

stories. Make your show collaborative instead of a one

Troy Lacher:

way, celebrate milestones together. Essentially your wins

Troy Lacher:

are also their wins be trans. Parent share behind the scene

Troy Lacher:

moments, the ups and the downs. People connect with the real,

Troy Lacher:

not that polished look. Help them connect with each other.

Troy Lacher:

Give them reasons to bond beyond just listening to you, and this

Troy Lacher:

is where it all pays off. Loyal listeners. Don't just consume

Troy Lacher:

your content. They act on it. They hire you, they recommend

Troy Lacher:

you. They become the foundation for growth you can actually

Troy Lacher:

sustain. That's the true fans idea in action. You don't need

Troy Lacher:

millions of downloads. You need the right group of committed

Troy Lacher:

people who believe in your message. So if you've been

Troy Lacher:

looking at your stats and feeling discouraged, stop

Troy Lacher:

comparing yourself to the Giants. That's not the path

Troy Lacher:

you're on. Your job is to take care of the people who are

Troy Lacher:

already showing up for you, because when you focus on

Troy Lacher:

connection and loyalty, your podcast becomes more than just

Troy Lacher:

another show, it becomes a trusted voice in someone's life,

Troy Lacher:

and that's what really matters. So until next time, happy

Troy Lacher:

podcasting.